There is a dropdown in every Google Ads campaign that decides whether you're paying for people in your service area or people merely thinking about it. It is collapsed by default, it is set per campaign, and Google's default value is the broad one.
Most local accounts never touch it. That's where a lot of "my leads are terrible" problems actually start.
Mistake 1: leaving Location options on the default
Under Settings → Locations, there's a section called Location options. It has two choices for your targeted locations:
- Presence or interest — people in, regularly in, or who've shown interest in your targeted locations. This is Google's default and its recommended setting.
- Presence — people in or regularly in your targeted locations.
"Shown interest" is wider than it sounds. Google says it may detect a location of interest from the terms in someone's search, their past searches, their past physical locations, Maps searches, or the content of a page they're viewing. It also notes that location of interest isn't restricted to a person's country or search domain — someone in Paris searching on google.fr can be matched to Los Angeles.
So a roofer targeting one metro can be shown to a person three states away who searched the city name while helping their parents find a contractor. That click costs the same as a real one.
Google does publish a reason for the default. Its help doc says advertisers who switched from Presence to Presence or Interest in the Travel, Real Estate, and Education verticals saw +5% more conversions on Search (Google internal data, global, 5/21/2022–6/1/2022). Read the verticals. Those are businesses where someone researching a place from far away is still a legitimate buyer. A customer who needs a drain cleared has to be standing in your service area.
The fix takes about thirty seconds per campaign: Settings → Locations → Location options → switch Target to "Presence." Expect impressions to drop. Google says so directly — most campaigns see fewer impressions when moving off the default. That's the point.
Mistake 2: checking the wrong location report
This is the one that convinces owners their targeting is fine when it isn't.
Google reports geography two ways, and they answer different questions:
- Matched locations shows the location Google used to match your ad. With the default setting, that can be a location of interest rather than anywhere the person actually was.
- User locations shows where the search was physically made from.
If you only look at matched locations, your report will look tidy — your targeted cities, right there, spending money. Meanwhile the humans generating those clicks could be anywhere. For a business that sends a truck, user locations is the honest report.
Also worth knowing: the Locations tab in your campaign settings is where you set targeting. The matched-locations view lives under the insights and reporting section, and user-location breakdowns are available through Report Editor. They are not the same screen, and the default view is rarely the useful one.
Mistake 3: assuming "Presence" means "standing in my town right now"
Presence means "in or regularly in." Commuters, people who work in your city and live two counties over, snowbirds, and anyone Google associates with the area on a recurring basis still qualify.
On top of that, Google states plainly that location targeting runs on signals — device settings, IP, GPS, Wi-Fi, cell tower data — and that 100% accuracy is not guaranteed in every situation. There is no switch that guarantees only people physically inside your boundary right now.
Presence is the correct setting for a local service business. It's a large improvement, not a wall.
Mistake 4: targeting a name instead of a boundary
Two versions of this:
The wrong place with the right name. Picking the country of Georgia instead of the state. Picking the wrong Springfield, Columbus, or Washington. The autocomplete happily accepts both. Open the map preview before you save — that single habit catches most of these.
The city limits aren't your market. When you target a city, Google may also serve nearby, closely related areas — its own example is that targeting Portland can also reach people in nearby suburbs. Targeting a city name does not draw a hard fence around the city line, and for most service businesses that's fine. Just don't assume the boundary on the map is the boundary of your spend.
Mistake 5: excluding in a way that backfires
Exclusions are more powerful than people realize, and they behave in two specific ways:
Exclusion beats inclusion. Google's example: exclude California, target Los Angeles, and Los Angeles gets nothing. Local version: a contractor excludes a whole county because most of it is out of range, not noticing that the one city they do want sits inside it. The campaign quietly loses its best area.
Exclusions are presence-based only. Google migrated exclusions so they block people likely located in the excluded area. They do not block people elsewhere who've shown interest in it. So if your targeting is still on Presence or Interest, piling on exclusions won't catch the interest traffic — fixing the Target setting does. (Google also removed the ability to set interest-only targeting on Search, Display and Shopping; the only real choice now is Presence vs. Presence or Interest.)
If you're cleaning up a wide target area, you can paste in up to 1,000 location exclusions at a time rather than adding them one by one.
Mistake 6: a radius drawn around your office
Radius targeting is convenient and slightly lazy. Your business address is rarely the center of your demand, and a circle doesn't understand a river, a toll bridge, a mountain, or an hour of traffic.
Two practical corrections. First, center the radius where the jobs are, not where your desk is. Second, if a meaningful chunk of the circle is somewhere you'd decline the job, either shrink it or switch to named locations — cities, counties, or postal codes — so you can control the edges precisely.
If you're running Performance Max with a pay-per-lead goal, Google's own guidance is to keep your service area within about two hours' driving time of your business location, and to keep all targeted service areas in the same country as your listing.
Mistake 7: fixing Search and forgetting everything else
Location options are a campaign-level setting. Change it on three campaigns and the fourth one you launch next month is back on the default. There's no account-wide toggle.
Performance Max is the usual offender, because people set it up through the guided flow and never expand the advanced sections. Google's own Performance Max lead-generation best practices say that if you're getting leads from outside your targeted areas, change location targeting from "Presence or interest" to "Presence: People in or regularly in your included locations."
One more reason this matters more than it used to: if out-of-area form fills are counted as conversions, Smart Bidding treats them as successes and goes looking for more people like that. Bad geo settings don't just waste today's clicks — they train the bidding against you. Out-of-area leads should be filtered at the source, not just ignored in your inbox.
A 15-minute audit
Do this on every active campaign:
- Settings → Locations → Location options. Set Target to Presence.
- Look at the map preview and confirm the places listed are the places you meant.
- Pull a location report, switch it to user locations, set a date range with real volume, and sort by cost descending.
- Read the top rows. Anywhere you can't or won't serve gets excluded.
- Check that your exclusions don't contain a city you're trying to target.
- Repeat for Performance Max. Then put it on your new-campaign checklist so it never drifts back.
Smart Bidding complicates the old habit of applying location bid adjustments — Google's position is that it already adjusts bids by location automatically. The levers that still reliably work are what you include and what you exclude.
This is a settings problem, which is why it's so common: nothing is broken, nothing is disapproved, and the account looks healthy right up until you compare where the money went to where your trucks go. If you'd rather work through the whole account in a defined order — targeting, tracking, structure, budget — instead of fixing one setting at a time, that's what the Launchpad system is for.
And if your out-of-area traffic turns out to be driven by city names in your search terms rather than by location settings, that's a different fix — see the negative keyword guide on this site.